![](https://i0.wp.com/blogs-images.forbes.com/markhughes/files/2014/03/CAPTAIN-AMERICA-75.jpg)
Oh, Marvel. Oh, Captain. Oh… Captain, my Captain.
Captain America is my favorite member of The Avengers, and though it wasn’t the best structurally, I probably enjoyed his Phase 1 movie the most for its adorable 40’s nostalgia charm. As such, I probably had a bit more to gain and a bit more to look forward to from this movie than, let’s say, major fans of the Iron Man movies did. I was really looking forward to seeing Steve Rogers again, and also Black Widow, who I thought was really underdeveloped in Iron Man 2. In order to balance out this review some, I’m going to try something a little bit new for me and do it in list format, starting with the things I liked and then covering the things I didn’t like.
What I Liked:
Characters:
All of the characters from previous Marvel movies got a lot of screentime and development in this movie. The characters didn’t just do things, they had actual arcs and journeys and grew as people beyond where they left off in Avengers. This was also a strength I thought Iron Man 3 had, but in Winter Soldier Black Widow’s development really stood out. She didn’t have much to accomplish in her first appearance in Iron Man 2, and even though Avenger’s gave her a personality, she didn’t have as much of a chance to stand out simply because of the size of the cast in that movie. In this movie, she has a lot of scenes one-on-one with Steve which allow both of the characters to show who they are in their element. They make snide comments, they joke, they try to poke at each other’s baggage, and I felt we got to learn a lot about them both from the way they were put together in this story.
As for Captain America himself, I liked how they didn’t go too far into the “Man Out of Time” storyline, since they kind of missed their chance with that in The Avengers, but they gave us enough of it to be satisfying. Instead, they actually gave us more time to see his personality, already pretty well developed, as it fits into a modern, non-superhero fighting team context. I especially really liked the way they handled this with his relationship with the Falcon. Speaking of…
There was one point in this movie where I was sitting there thinking, “Wow, I wonder if little kids could get anything from this…” Then, immediately after that thought, The Falcon has a scene where he is dodging airborn missiles with his mechanical bird wings. And I was like, “Oh!” In other words, I really liked the Falcon (his name is Sam, by the way). Sam is introduced as the first non-Shield, non-Super person Steve befriends in the 21st century, and even though he obviously becomes a hero later in the movie, I liked the relationship with him and a seemingly normal ex-army guy working for the VA. Their personalities mesh well, they have a lot of funny back and forth, and I really look forward to more of their team ups in the future.
Oh, right, the Winter Soldier. The one from the title. We’ll get to him. But I liked his design?
Themes:
Making a modern action movie with themes about mistrust of the government, spying on individuals, drones, and government infiltration by terrorists is by no means unexpected or mind-blowing, but I do appreciate that is is somewhat more daring to do this in a movie titled “Captain America” (and some type of Winter Soldier or something). The incorporation of the references to the modern day with current American fears about government control mixed with just enough comic book unreality to make them fantastical gave a nice balance and an interesting tone. The movie allowed itself to touch on the heavier issues, but was enough of a comic book movie that it could do so in a broad, optimistic way that would have otherwise seemed pandering.
Oh, and yes. The villains are literally using aerial drones. Okay, they’re not drones, but they’re not trying to hide the inspiration.
The Action:
I have some mixed feelings on the action in this movie, but what did really stand out to me was how brutal it was. A lot of things get destroyed, and a lot of people get killed in the crossfire. I’m not a hundred percent sure what made it more intense to me than, let’s say, Thor 2, but I think it was the angle from which the action was filmed. I hate shakey cam, but in this movie they used it pretty effectively (and somewhat sparingly) to make you feel like you were watching it from ten feet away. It also has somewhat to do with who they showed getting caught in the crossfire. There’s a part near the end when a bunch of people are called upon to “fight for their freedom”, and even as you’re hearing them being called to action you see a lot of them being killed. The extras don’t really have any “hero immunity”, and it was actually pretty striking.
Okay, now it’s time to movie onto
What I Didn’t Like:
The Amount of Storylines:
I loved the Falcon, and I’m intrigued by The Winter Soldier. The only problem is, neither of these characters has much of a connection to the main plot! The Winter Soldier is an assassin for/agent of the main baddies, okay. Functionally, he’s more of a subplot. The Falcon is interesting, but he really doesn’t get enough time to develop as a hero, or as a friend to the main characters. If the movie had moved more of the Winter Soldier subplot to the end of the movie, as a teaser to the third movie that is already going to feature him, or removed Falcon to save him for the next movie, the plot would have had more time to develop and felt a whole lot less cluttered.
Lack of Humor:
One of my favorite elements of the first Captain America movie was how it managed to have a lot of humor, both from it’s snarky characters and its situations, while still dealing with character development and dramatic action. In the sequel, though there are a few funny scenes and gags, the tone remains fairly serious throughout. It may work for some people, but I like my Superhero movies to be a little more balanced on their humor and their drama.
Some Tonally Weird Nonsense:
Most of the movie has a great, consistent, “Trust No One” kind of tone to it, but there are a few moments for which that tone just does not work at all. The big reveal of who the villains are working for would be great, but the device used to reveal it, even though I can totally see it working in a Marvel comic, feels incredibly bizarre considering the realism that the rest of the movie is aiming for. There is also a bit of a deus ex machina that is incredibly predictable, and I thought that, with the serious tone they were trying to go for, undermined their purpose a bit.
Complete and Utter Nonsense:
Okay, I know I know I know, this is the most nitpicky thing. but there is a scene where a character gives Black Widow’s birth year as 1984, and then, two scenes later, she mentions that she used to be in the KGB. WHEN WERE YOU IN THE KGB? THE KGB WAS DISSOLVED IN 1991! Thing is, they didn’t even HAVE to say she was in the KGB! We could have all suspended our disbelief and gone on happily thinking that she was from some other super Russian spy agency, but NOOOOO. You had to make it explicitly the freaking KGB like this is 1985, and now it’s just stupid.
Overall, besides horrible KGB references, I can’t really say I disliked this movie. The tone was off to me, and they really should have left either Winter Soldier or The Falcon to the third movie, but I enjoyed watching it a lot, and it didn’t let down the Marvel Universe. Would I have liked better? Yes, definitely, and I really hope that they give the third movie maybe just another re-write or something to keep it from having the bugs that this one did. Did I hate it? No, not at all. It tried a lot of things, it succeeded in most of them, and it left me wanting more from The Avengers: Age of Ultron.